Understanding Efficiency

Efficiency is a commonly discussed subject among all grain brewers. But with the abundance of definitions for it, it easily becomes a matter of comparing apples with oranges. This article tries to shed some light on the various efficiency definitions that are in place and how they are defined (sometimes differently, depending on the author).

In "How To Brew", John Palmer defined the brewing efficiency as the ratio between the gravity points of the wort in the kettle and the maximum potential (labratory extract) of the grain. The maximum potential of the grain is given in gravity units per pound and gallon. Based on that the gravity points of the kettle wort are [Palmer 2005]:

kettle gravity points = brewing efficiency * grain amount in pound * kettle volume * potential of the grains

When grains with different potential are used, the weighted average of their potential needs to be used in the above equation.

In "Designing Great Beers", Ray Daniels defines what John Palmer calls brewing efficiency as mash efficiency [Daniels, 2000].

In "Abriss der Bierbrauerei", German brewing author Ludwig Narziss defines Sudhausausbeute (German for brew house efficiency) as the ratio between the amount of extract that made it into the boil kettle vs. the amount of grain that was used [Narziss, 2005]:

Sudhausausbeute = (kettle volume in l * kettle extract in % * kettle specific gravity) / grain mass in kg

Note that this is a different approach for defining the efficiency. The reference is not the maxium amount of extract that can be extracted from the grain, but the total weight of the grain. The latter includes the weight of the husks and other insoluble material. Because of that the the Sudhausausbeute is also affected by the potential (or laboratory extract) of the used grains. This is also the definition that German home brewers use for efficiency. Thus care needs to be taken when reading efficiency numbers from German sources. While 75% is a very good efficiency number when based on the total grain weight (most grains laboratory extract is about 80% of their weight) it is only a modest efficiency when it was based on the laboratory extract of the grain.

When asked how to calculate efficiency, the BYO Wizard replied with the same definition as was given in Narziss [BYO]. He calls that efficiency the brewhouse efficiency. But he also goes on and defines the efficiency that is based on the laboratory extract of the grain as brewhouse yield:

brewhouse yield = (kettle volume in l * kettle extract in % * kettle specific gravity) / (grain mass in kg * fine grind extract in %)

Furthermore, technical brewing articles oftentimes make mention of the Overall Brewhouse Yield (OBY). This is is defined like the BYO Wizard defined the brewhouse yield. It is affected by milling, mashing and lautering and basically indicates how close these brewhouse processes came to the fine grind laboratory extract.

BYO Wizard: Defines brewhouse efficiency the same as Narziss does. He also defines brewhouse yield as the ratio between the brewhouse efficiency and the weighted average of the grains laboratory yields.

Beersmith: defines 3 types of efficiency: brewhouse efficiency based on target volume, efficiency into boiler, efficiency into fermenter:

Sources

[Palmer, 2006] John J. Palmer, How to Brew, Brewers Publications, Boulder CO, 2006

[Daniels, 2000] Ray Daniels, Designing Great Beers, Brewers Publications, Boulder CO, 2000

[BYO], Online article Gravity & Brewhouse Efficiency